Who was/is the best thunderclan medicine cat?

I vote yellowfang. She might have been a little bossy to her apprentice, but she taught cinderpelt well and was bossy for a reason-she got things done. "What are standing around talking for? We need juniper berries!....Come on, we don't have all day! We have to get Catmint before moonhigh!

No, these are not actual quotes. I made them up.

I agree, Yellow Fang really did rock.
I, personally am sick of Jaypaw...
He's so obnoxious!

Yeah, he is pretty anonying. Poor yellowfang, have you read the Warriors field guide, Secrets of the clans?

Spottedleaf is so the best medicine cat. She went the extra step to find the other cats and to give them help.

Yellowfang! (duh, to the people who know me) Jaypaw and Cinderpelt are cool too.

Yellowfang was awesome! She is so strong yet she been through so much.

That is true, yellowfang was my second chioce, but spottedleaf was kinder and was so helpful even out in Skyclan.

Yes, but her stupid son exiled her. If he hadn't been leader she probably would have never been a thunderclan medicine cat.

But it was a good thing he exiled her, though it was for no reason, because then she helped thunderclan and was loved in more than one clan. Because let's face it, only brokenstar and his followers hated her, not all of Shadowclan was Evil and mean to her. Like i have said before, Shadowclan is not comepletely evil, just some of the leaders and other cats in shadowclan. Tawneypelt, Yellowfang, Blackstar(sort of, cuz he hasn't done anything bad so far), and Raggedstar(Although he was kind of stupid not to see how evil his son was).

kittypet12 wrote:But it was a good thing he exiled her, though it was for no reason, because then she helped thunderclan and was loved in more than one clan. Because let's face it, only brokenstar and his followers hated her, not all of Shadowclan was Evil and mean to her. Like i have said before, Shadowclan is not comepletely evil, just some of the leaders and other cats in shadowclan. Tawneypelt, Yellowfang, Blackstar(sort of, cuz he hasn't done anything bad so far), and Raggedstar(Although he was kind of stupid not to see how evil his son was).

but they do seem to always have something sinister up there coat. (get it? not sleeve?

sop4257 wrote:

kittypet12 wrote:But it was a good thing he exiled her, though it was for no reason, because then she helped thunderclan and was loved in more than one clan. Because let's face it, only brokenstar and his followers hated her, not all of Shadowclan was Evil and mean to her. Like i have said before, Shadowclan is not comepletely evil, just some of the leaders and other cats in shadowclan. Tawneypelt, Yellowfang, Blackstar(sort of, cuz he hasn't done anything bad so far), and Raggedstar(Although he was kind of stupid not to see how evil his son was).

but they do seem to always have something sinister up there coat. (get it? not sleeve?

lol. Yes, but I think they seem like that so they can keep their clan personality. After all, that is what shadowclan is all about. Being mischievous, sneaky, strong, and proud of it!

and thats why i love them! i think it was smart of yellowfang to blind her son instead of killing him!

I liked Cinderpelt because she could be mean, and fieshty [] , or really kind and sweet. She always supported Firestar, and did a good job training Leafpool. I was so sad when she died.

i couldn't beleive it was tigerclaw's fault she (cinderpelt) got crippled (or a broken leg, whichever you prefer). i love cinderpelt! but I'm not sure if she would have made a very good warrior. she was oveousley made to me a medicen cat!