The most Evil Cat

Which cat was the most evil while alive in the Forest?? (or in Cat's dreams)

- I vote Tigerstar. He was the one who brought Scorge to the forest, ended up killing Bluestar tried to take over the forest, and is still trying to lead Lionpaw in training. He also trained Hawkfrost to fight in special movements. And tried to get Brambleclaw to join him.

I voted Hawkfrost because he tried to kill firestar (well Tigerstar did too). He lied to a medicine cat. He is just plain mean.

This is a toughy. I would have to say Brokenstar because he trained kits to be warriors at like, 2 moons old! And he killed is own father(which I don't think is very nice.) I would probably pick scourge as last place in this poll.I mean, sure he tried to take over the forest but at least he was polite about it(not to mention he has an actual reason to hate the clans.)

Well I guess brokenstar is pretty bad (he was mean to my favorite character)

Windstripe wrote:Well I guess brokenstar is pretty bad (he was mean to my favorite character)

Your favorite character brought that terror into the world of warriors.

So, what is your point.

Icewing wrote:

Windstripe wrote:Well I guess brokenstar is pretty bad (he was mean to my favorite character)

Your favorite character brought that terror into the world of warriors.

--As in it's your favorite charactor's fault that he was ever born, or else he wouldn't have been mean to her.

kittypet12 wrote:

Icewing wrote:

Windstripe wrote:Well I guess brokenstar is pretty bad (he was mean to my favorite character)

Your favorite character brought that terror into the world of warriors.

--As in it's your favorite charactor's fault that he was ever born, or else he wouldn't have been mean to her.

You know, it isn't Yellowfangs fault she had a twisted, demented kit. She didn't raise him you know!

Windstripe wrote:
You know, it isn't Yellowfangs fault she had a twisted, demented kit. She didn't raise him you know!

It was her fault she had a kit in the first place, though. And yes, lizardstripe, an ambitious queen, raised brokenstar.

It isn't her fault he was evil.

But she's a medicine cat, so starclan punished her for falling in love and breaking the warrior code!!

Windstripe wrote:

kittypet12 wrote:

Icewing wrote:

Windstripe wrote:Well I guess brokenstar is pretty bad (he was mean to my favorite character)

Your favorite character brought that terror into the world of warriors.

--As in it's your favorite charactor's fault that he was ever born, or else he wouldn't have been mean to her.

You know, it isn't Yellowfangs fault she had a twisted, demented kit. She didn't raise him you know!

your right icewing. "i thought my punishment was having all of my kits but died, but my real punishment is that this one survived." (yes, that is a real quote.) poor yellowfang, having to be tortured by knowing that your son has killed the love of your life.

Yes I feel so sorry for her. I really need to catch up on the stories!!

Yellowfang didnt deserve to die for some elder. She could have saved the clan in the future. it was her fault ultimently. She had the kit that banned her from Shadowclan.

But she felt sorry for it. I liked Yellowfang. StarClan did punish her, and she accepted it. She admitted she was wrong. But she killed Brokentail in the end. And I think, in a way, that was another part of Firestar's destiny, to save his clan.

it was smart of her to make it look like an accident, the way she killed brokentail. it was suprising! i thought someone like sandstorm would kill him! but his own MOTHER! wow! did not see that comeing!